After talking to my friend Liz about this topic last week (except we didn’t call it that), I’ve been thinking a lot about different paradigms we uphold as Christians, and whether or not they are helpful or true.
For example, sometimes I unconsciously view my walk with God as a combination of theory and practicals. Spiritual growth comes from two separate areas – gaining knowledge from the Word of God, and the Spirit’s practical influence in my life. The key is to get the right balance between both. Yes, I want to be rooted in the Bible and learning all I can about the truths of God, but this is incomplete if I don’t supplement the Word with “practical lessons”, i.e. allowing the Spirit to teach me to be more loving through day-to-day encounters, revelations through prayer and other experiences.
There are many ways I subscribe to this uni-degree type model. Often, I’ve plugged in the formula ‘bible-reading plus experiencing God equals a healthy, balanced Christian life’. Or when I was younger, thinking, “church A is where I go for the solid teaching, whereas church B is where I feel spiritually connected to God”.
But is this a false dichotomy? Can you separate the head from the heart? The Bible is not an academic textbook, but the Word of God inspired by the Holy Spirit, living and active in our lives. It can’t be separated from day to day living, nor can it be divorced from the active work of the Spirit in our lives.
On the other hand, we are also taught by God to test the spirits and weigh up every prophecy. When Paul instructs the Corinthians on proclaiming prophecies in the church, he commands them to do so without abandoning order, selflessness or reason. I don’t think there is a point experiencing the work of the Holy Spirit is to happen at the expense of clear, comprehensible thought.
So here we have a false dichotomy. To separate an emotional response to God from an intelligent grasp of His will – the heart from the head – is to promote a faith without reason (and downplay the impact the knowledge of God should have on our responses. As John Piper says, if we truly grasp the character and mind of God, we should be filled with the most overwhelming, wonderful joy). Likewise, to treat His Word as a mere theological exercise and view our emotional response as a trivial matter for day-to-day living is to deny its power as living and active, divinely inspired by the Holy Spirit.
John Stott, who I’ve been reading today while sick from work, exposes another false dichotomy between the personal and propositional revelation of God. The personal refers to God’s individual revelation to a particular people in a certain time and space. The propositional is God’s revelation as it matters on a universal scale, i.e. the revelation as recorded by the apostles and writers of the Bible. He says:
This is a false distinction. God’s self-revelation was indeed mostly personal – through acts of salvation and judgment. But how could such events be beneficial to those not involved in them unless there were witnesses to record and interpret the events?…Thus God’s special revelation was usually a combination of deed and word, event and testimony. We should not therefore perpetuate the myth that God’s revelation could be personal without being proposition too, deeds without words. (Evangelical Truth)
Maybe the answer is not finding a balance between two dichotomies, but adopting a paradigm that allows the Christian to keep both seemingly opposing concepts as equally true - without flattening the tension between them. It sounds complicated, but we do it all the time (how can God be good and still allow evil? How can God be fully in control, yet we are still accountable for our sin?).
The only way we can do this is to fully grasp, in our hearts and minds, the glorious wisdom of God, the goodness of His grace, the wonder of His wisdom, which frustrates even the most intelligent amongst us. This isn't an abandonment of our desire to know God more, a resigned "oh well, I guess God will be God and there's nothing I can do about it". Instead, it's about having Christ dwell in your heart so you may understand this, about having what Paul prays for in Ephesians:
I pray that you, being rooted and established in love, may have power together with the saints to grasp how wide and long and high and deep is the love of Christ, and to know this love that surpasses knowledge - that you may be filled to the measure of all the fullness of God.
P.S. I'm sure there are many inaccuracies in what I've written, but please try to grab the general spirit of what I'm trying to say when you correct me!